Welcome to the Bastion

In general, I’m wary of public nostalgia. Way I see it, older generations have an obligation to step aside as new ones come into their own.  And new generations have a right to forge their own paths to the future, turning traditions on their head, or enshrining them, or transforming them, as they see fit.

I even think that’s true when it comes to my all-time favorite hobby, Dungeons & Dragons.  So though I cut my first swath on the 2nd edition advanced rules of the game that changed games forever, I mostly kept my piece when the much-loathed (by many) 3.X editions emerged.  Sure, I resisted the switch for a time, but the more I examined the then-new version, the more I liked what I saw.

Eventually, I jumped whole-hog into the 3.X rules, and pretty much ignored the brewing Edition Wars. I packed away my old boxed sets, sold off a lot of my 2nd edition supplements, and forged ahead with ascending Armor Classes, the unified Experience Point Table, prestige classes, and monster templates.  Wizards Of The Coast, the company that had bought the rights to D&D, took the absolutely generous and genius move of making the game’s core rules open source, so that 3rd-party small-press publishers could have the opportunity to release their own quirky, unique, brilliant, disturbing, inspirational, or otherwise “different” fantasy games as part of a widely-recognized and respected brand.  I probably spent hundreds of dollars over the years, gobbling up all that creativity, wondering when I’d ever find the time to run or play in all these amazing games.

Meanwhile, a curious  thing happened, over where I wasn’t looking.  Some players, nostalgic for the old ways, noticed that the Open Game Licence legally allowed them to replicate and publish their own games using the rules of older versions of D&D.  And so, they did.

At first, it was just a few projects that re-assembled and/or re-organized the given publisher’s preferred version.  But it didn’t take long for some of these publishers to start tweaking the old rules in their own ways, turning them into something new.

Me?  I didn’t really start noticing this “Old School Renaissance” until relatively recently.  I didn’t like the official 4th edition all that much, and there were many things about the 3.x that I was having second thoughts about.  News of the impending 5th edition led me to download and read the playtest packet out of curiosity, and much of what I saw there looked… old, but different.

The core of the D&D Next rules is more distilled than what I’d been used to since making the switch to 3.x  It read like a simpler edition of the game from days of yore, yet incorporated modern concepts.  This intrigued me, and while chatting about it with some grognards at my friendly neighborhood  game store (hereafter known as FNGS), I was clued in to the existence of “retro-clones” and the “Old School Renaissance” — which, of course, most of them preferred. And which, of course, most of them insisted was the reason the D&D Next rules looked like an attempt to integrate all previous editions into one.  Market pressure, and all that.

And, finally, the grognards clued me in to the fact that a great deal of these retro-clone games are 100 percent free to download.

Upon investigation, I found a wealth of creative resources designed to evoke the feel of the old days while still moving forward… and, not the least concern, to take a lot of prep work off of the beleaguered Dungeon Master’s shoulders.  As a rules-lazy DM, I was pretty much sold.  Despite my usual objections to public nostalgia.

So, here I am, a goblin-come-lately to the Old School Renaissance.  I don’t know yet whether I’ll end up supporting and playing the 5th edition.  I’m currently running a 3.x game that I and  my players are enjoying.

And in the meantime, I’m starting this blog to write reviews of the various OSR games I’ve found, to show them off to my small readership (which will probably just be my friends for a while), and to stockpile some of my own brainstorms and game ideas (because I have way more of them in my head than I’ll probably ever use, and I figure at least this way others might get to do something with them).

So, welcome to Bobgoblin’s Bastion.  I hope you enjoy your stay.

About thebobgoblin

It's true. Birds are dinosaurs.
This entry was posted in General Remarks and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Welcome to the Bastion

  1. I was personally a little disappointed in the most recent play test packet for DDN. I’ve waffled on whether I like what I see or not and finally received in the August packet the baited hook with the removal of skills entirely in favor of lores and background specialties. Unfortunately for me these things returned in the latest packet along with new content like the Dragonborn race… which is still going to be a core race? I thought they were (probably should) going to let it die with 4th Edition. For me at least the latest, and final, packet was a step back. It’s design safe and familiar, though I was under the impression D&D wanted to grow not stay the same.

    But, good post and hope to see more from you in the future.

    • thebobgoblin says:

      Hey, thanks for visiting and being the first person to comment on my blog. I suppose there ought to be a prize for that, but oh well.

      I have no objections to the dragonborn or any other core race, old or new school. I don’t think D&D ought to be shoe-horned forever into Tolkien spin-offs. And I’m not even opposed to a skills system, in principle. Many gamers were house-ruling such things before 3.x, and will continue doing so whatever form DDN takes.

      For me, the second thoughts come in with the bookkeeping commitment of high-level play in the new school rules. I saw, upon the one time I read the 4e Player’s Handbook, that some of that had been streamlined, but 4e still didn’t do “it” for me. In any case, there was just too much for DMs and high-level players to keep track of; and I think in application, a lot of the design elements like feats and skills ended up undermining their own purpose, becoming straight jackets instead of expanded options (“oh, no Swim skill… sucks for you, kraken bait”).

      Plus, I’ve found that a lot of people don’t like doing math when they’re trying to slay a dragon. I suspect some of the new school players I game with might actually appreciate having a table to look at that will tell them exactly what they need to roll, rather than having to read the fine print on their character sheets and break out a slide rule. We’ll see, when they start giving me feedback about the OSR reviews.

      Again, thanks for being my first poster. You win a +5 vorpal keyboard.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s